Creatine HCl Ya Fi Monohydrate a Ƙwallon Kafa – Kada Ka Manta da Shi Yanzu
Bincike sabo da aka yi a ‘yan wasa 40 na ƙwallon ƙafa ya nuna cewa creatine HCl da creatine ethyl‑ester sun ba da ƙaruwa a tsalle, gudu, juyawa da ƙarfin kololu fiye da monohydrate bayan makonni huɗu kacal. Kodayake kowane irin creatine ya doke placebo, sakamakon yana da iyakoki – ƙungiyar da aka bincika ta ƙunshi ’yan wasa 10 a kowanne rukuni, ba a bayyana adadin da aka ba su ba, kuma ba ya daidaita da binciken da aka yi a baya. Wannan ke nan ke nuna abin da aka gani, abin da ba a gani ba, da yadda ya kamata a yi la’akari da shi.
Kadarar da aka ba Kre‑Alkalyn ba ta haɓaka matakin creatine a tsoka, binciken biopsies ya nuna
Creatine mai ruɓutewa kamar Kre‑Alkalyn ana ikirarin yana da shaƙa mai kyau, yana buƙatar ƙananan ƙima, kuma ba ya haifar da kumburi. Binciken double‑blind na Texas A&M ya yi amfani da biopsies na tsoka daga masu ɗaukar nauyi 36 a tsawon kwanaki 28. A ƙimar da aka ba da shawara, wato 1.5 g a rana, matakin creatine a tsoka bai ƙaru ba, yayin da monohydrate ya ƙaru sosai. Babu fa'ida a cikin ƙarfi, girman jiki, ko tasirin gefe ga samfurin ruɓutewa. Ga abin da sakamakon ya nuna da yadda za a ɗauki creatine daidai.
Creatine Pyruvate vs Citrate: Wanne Tsari Ne Ya Riƙe Ƙarfi Na Dogon Lokaci
A gwajin kwanaki 28, nau’ukan creatine biyu sun yi tasiri fiye da placebo, amma ɗaya kaɗai ne ya ci gaba da ƙara ƙarfin tsoka har zuwa ƙarshen gwajin. Creatine pyruvate ya ƙara ƙarfin a kowane zagaye (p < 0.001), yayin da fa'idar creatine citrate ta ƙare bayan zagaye na shida. Pyruvate shi ne kawai ya inganta saurin sassauta tsoka da kuma yawan amfanin iskar oxygen a lokacin hutu. Ka lura da babbar ƙuntatawa: binciken bai haɗa ƙungiyar creatine monohydrate ba.
Creatine Ethyl Ester da Monohydrate: Tsarin Da Ya Fi Tsada Ba Ya Ba da Fa'ida
Masu sana'ar ƙarin gina jiki kan talla da “creatine mai ci gaba” a matsayin wadda ke shigarwa mafi kyau da ƙarfin tasiri. A wani bincike na 2009, an kwatanta creatine ethyl ester (CEE) da creatine monohydrate (CRT) da kuma placebo a kan maza 30 marasa horo na tsawon makonni bakwai na ɗaukar nauyi. CEE ya haifar da ƙarancin matakin creatine a jini amma ya ƙara matakin creatinine sosai, alamar rushewa. Duk da cewa an samu ƙaruwa a matakin creatine a tsoka daga duka rukunan, ba a ga bambanci a ƙarfi, ƙarfin juriya ko girman jiki ba. Darasin da ya taso: guji tsarin da ya fi tsada, ka ci gaba da amfani da monohydrate da ke da sauƙi da ƙima.